S&P 500 Index Fund Comparison - Not All Index Funds Are Great!

Index funds have a lot of fans in the investing world, and it’s easy to see why. They are known for their low expenses, and there’s plenty of articles and studies that show index funds beat actively managed funds, but not all index funds were created equal.

Here are 6 index funds that claim to track the S&P 500 index. You’d think they’d be virtually identical. Think again.

I’m comparing these funds on only 2 parameters: Total fees (as reported by Yahoo! finance) and annual turnover rate.

Fidelity Spartan 500 Index Inv (FUSEX)

Fees: 0.10%
Annual Holdings Turnover (Jun 4, 2010) : 11.00%

Vanguard 500 Index Investor (VFINX)

Fees: 0.18%
Annual Holdings Turnover (Jun 4, 2010) : 12.00%

Schwab S&P 500 Index (SWPPX)

Fees: 0.13%
Annual Holdings Turnover (Jun 4, 2010) : 3.00%

DWS S&P 500 Index B (SXPBX)

Fees: 1.37%
Annual Holdings Turnover (Jun 4, 2010) : 9.00%

State Farm S&P 500 Index B (SNPBX)

Fees: 1.50%
Annual Holdings Turnover (Jun 4, 2010) : 5.00%

Rydex S&P 500 C (RYSYX)

Fees: 2.28%
Annual Holdings Turnover (Jun 4, 2010) : 58.00%

As you can see, not only are these funds are not equal but they are actually quite different. There’s over 2% points difference in the fees, and over 50% difference in the turnover rate!

The fees I could understand, since some brokerages are going to charge more. One may not be as efficient as another, or maybe they just have higher marketing overhead. But the turnover is ridiculous on a fund that should track an index of a known 500 stocks. I mean, 58% turnover on an S&P 500 index is just insane!

There’s no excuse for it. Well, I mean there is because they must be doing some fancy options or shorting voodoo in an effort to boost returns, but it isn’t working. Just look at this comparison of the Schwab S&P 500 Index and the Rydex S&P 500 C:

A comparison of 5 year performance for SWPPX, RYSYX and the S&P 500 index

Not only does the Rydex cost over 2% more in fees, but the turnover rate is 55% more (which means potentially higher taxes if you hold it in a taxable account) but its performance lags both the Schwab fund and the index it’s meant to track!

I’m at a loss to explain why an informed investor would ever choose this fund. In fact, the performance of the Fidelity Spartan 500 Index Inv, Vanguard 500 Index Investor and
Schwab S&P 500 Index is pretty much a wash:

A comparison of the 5 year performance of FUSEX, VFINX, SWPPX and the S&P 500 index.

So, I’d probably pick the Fidelity Spartan, unless only one of the others was available. But that’s just me. ;-)

Related Posts
  • 6 Ways Dividends Are Important. Dividends are an important part of investing - especially if you are an income or value investor. Investing for income is all about dividend yield, but dividends have many other virtues - even if generating income from your investments isn't of paramount concern. Dividends are a large part of a......
  • Ivy League Investing For The Common Man. David Swensen has managed the Yale University endowment from 1984 to 2008 and during that time, the endowment returned an annualized 16.6% - 5 points better than the S&P 500 and a generic balanced portfolio of 60% in a stock index, and 40% in bond index. That equates to a......
  • Morningstar Announces Their Best Fund Managers of 2009! Morningstar has released their picks for Best Mutual Fund Managers of 2009. It's important to remember that the competition is intended as an acknowledgement of past achievements, not as a recommendation for future performance.. That being said, the rankings are determined by a number of factors, not just best return......
  • 3 Structured CDs With Big Potential. Structured CDs (Certificates of Deposit) offer some upside under certain market conditions of environments where traditional CDs only offer safety of principal. In a general sense, the value of a structured CD is based on some underlying asset. This is usually done by the use of some kind of index......
  • A Sample ETF Portfolio for 100% Foreign Exposure. Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) offer broad diversity in a single package, and if the ETF is an index fund then they carry added tax benefits when compared to actively manage mutual funds. When ETFs first hit the investment scene, they were simple index tracking funds. They mainly targeted passive investors.......

Related Websites
  • Wealth Builder Ratios - Q1 2010 Update Here is our Q1 2010 Wealth Builder Ratio update. During the first quarter of 2010, the Dow, Nasdaq and S&P500 indices advanced 4.1%, 5.7% and 4.9% respectively. My company stock matched the indices and gained 5.1% during Q1. As it turns out, our savings, including company stock options are also......
  • Ballena Isle Marina  Ballena Isle Marina is located in Alameda, CA Phone: 510.523.5528 View Larger Map Website: http://www.ballenaisle.com/ Available Slips: 515 Current Pricing: 22' - $170 per month. Rates go as high as $902 for 70' vessels. Please visit their website for more complete pricing information. What You Need to Know About Pricing:......
  • Making Year End Adjustments to Your Investment Portfolio If you are an investor still contemplating whether to make adjustments to your asset allocations in your investment portfolio, you are running out of time.  We have only a few trading days left in 2008.  You may be looking to harvest some tax losses.  That shouldn't be hard to do.  You could......
  • Mutual Funds 101 One way that investors can pool their money is mutual funds, which allows them to invest together in a variety of different stocks. Each of the participating investors is charged a percentage fee based on what they invest so that the professional fund manager can receive payment for his work......
  • Cordova Golf Course, Sacramento, CA Cordova Golf Course is located in: Sacramento, CA Phone: (916) 362-1196   Website: http://www.cordovagc.com Course History: This course was first built in 1958 and became very popular due to its low rates and terrific play. They are very friendly to players of all skill levels and the prices really are......

Leave a Reply




You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>