Nov 11 2009

5 Things to Do When You Have a Bad 401(k) Plan.

401(k) plans can be a great way to save for retirement and let your savings grow tax-free. But the plans are chosen by employers and managed by 3rd parties and don’t always have the best options. IRAs give you the entire universe of investments to choose from, but most employers offer a free match on a percentage of contributions to the 401(k) plans by the employee. So what’s an employee to do when the 401(k) plan has lousy investment options?

Here are 5 options, though there may be more.

1. Be an index hugger.

If your 401(k) plan offers index funds, then you can still get broad-based exposure and diversification at a low cost. You won’t be beating the market, but you won’t under perform the market either.

2. Take the best and move on.

If your 401(k) plan has one or two excellent funds and a dozen other mediocre funds, take the one or two and skip the others. This may seem like you’re not properly diversifying, but you should consider your entire collection of assets when diversifying, not just a single account.

For example, say your 401(k) plan has one excellent blue chip stock fund, and an equally excellent small cap stock fund, but the bond funds are lousy. You should invest in the stock funds offered by your 401(k) and invest the overall bond allocation in some other account, like an IRA account or maybe your spouse’s 401(k). Each individual account will be non-diversified, but when taken together your total assets will be diversified.

3. Look into the “window”.

More and more large employers are offering 401(k) plans with a “brokerage window” or “self-directed accounts.” These options allow the employee access to hundreds or thousands of other mutual funds, ETF’s and even individual stocks that aren’t part of the standard 401(k) plans options.

Be sure to investigate the details and learn about any additional fees or transaction costs that may be associated with the use of the “window”. There may be additional work on your end as well, since this option is unlikely to be available for automatic contributions like the standard 401(k) options. You may need to fill out additional paperwork or make other such declarations.

4. Talk to HR.

If you think your 401(k) plan stinks and you can get other coworkers to join you, you can petition your HR department to change the plan, or go with a new plan provider altogether. The more employees unhappy with the status quo, the more likely you can get your employer to change things.

5. Check out other options.

If all else fails, you can always go it alone with an IRA account. But if you get a company match on your contributions, then pick the best fund that’s offered and contribute at least enough to get the full company match and put the rest in an IRA. There’s no point in passing up free money, no matter how lousy the fund options are.


Related Posts
  • Reliability of Income, the New ROI. The 2008-2009 market crash and resulting bear market have been absolutely brutal to new retirees and soon to be retirees alike. For those in my age set (about 30 years out from retirement) it serves as a poignant lesson of what can go wrong. To Mary Beth Franklin, editor of......
  • Beware the Ides of March? Technically speaking, the Ides of March is nothing more than a date on the Roman calendar. March 15th, to be exact. But it has sinister implications because it just so happens that the Roman emperor, Julius Caesar, was stabbed to death on March 15th 44 BC by the very senators......
  • The simple 7 investment portfolio. Looking for an easy, diversified portfolio of stock funds that will grow your money over time, but won't take over your life with demands on your time? ladies, gentlemen and undeclared's, I present the simple 7 portfolio.. Each recommendation is either an ETF, or a no-load mutual fund. Some people......
  • Top Morningstar Bond Funds for July 2009. Morningstar has released their top 3 Bond Funds for June-July. Here's the list: High-yield bonds. T. Rowe Price Spectrum Income (RPSIX) This is a fund of funds. The management team invests in up to 9 T. Rowe Price funds in order to get exposure to all of the sectors of......
  • 3 Tips to Make Your 401(k) Work for You. Morningstar has a terrific article (available to free members) titled Three Tips to Make Your 401(k) Work for You and I love it! Here's a brief sample of why: It's surprising there aren't many calls in the press to ditch the automobile. After all, think of all the dumb things......

Related Websites
  • 7 Online Discount Brokers That Offer Stock Trades for $7 Or Less This article comes from DR at The Dough Roller, a blog about how to make more money, spend less, and invest the rest. As investors have become more and more comfortable trading stocks and options over the Internet, a number of online discount brokers have entered the market. Zecco was......
  • Why 401(k) Can Spell "Lousy Retirement Plan" Mr. ToughMoneyLove doesn't have have a pension plan or a golden parachute.  When I leave my job for good, my employer will say thanks (by then, probably more like "thanks for finally leaving") and cut me a small check for the book value of my stock in the business.  ......
  • What if Your Employer Stops Matching 401k Contributions? It is unfortunate to read about so many businesses cutting costs by reducing or eliminating the match of their employees' 401(k) contributions.  This is a particularly devastating blow to the retirement plans of baby boomers who have been depending on the employer match to rebuild dwindling 401k account balances.  Fortunately, this......
  • Open A ShareBuilder Investment Account, Get $25 I came across another top broker promotion, and this time, it’s from ShareBuilder, the online stock broker arm for ING Direct, a highly regarded online bank. At this time, they are offering a $25 cash bonus to new investors who would like to open an Individual, Joint or Custodial......
  • Choosing the Right Types of Investments pt 2 If company stock is the only option that is available to you through your company's offered 401 k savings plan, then you should be looking at other types of investment vehicles to handle some of your savings for retirement. Annuities When you decide to buy an annuity, what you have......

Leave a Reply

Search Engine Submission - AddMe